The Disintegrating Fabric of Tunisian Politics: The Niqab Ban and Tunisian Flag Desecration at Manouba University

It’s difficult to say how it started. For clarity’s sake, let’s begin on November 28, 2011. Enraged at the University’s enforcement of the niqab ban, a group of Salafists took the Dean of the College of Letters at Manouba University hostage. (Students at Manouba, and at universities around the country, are prohibited by presidential decree from wearing the niqab while in class).[1]

Protestors, swelling at times to 200, came to the defense of female students wishing to wear the niqab to exams.[2] They leafleted the campus with fliers crying, “Sister, What is Preventing You From Wearing the Niqab?” Leftist students, oftentimes members of the student political union Union Générale des Étudiantes (UGET), responded with the familiar cry of the revolution, “degage, degage.”

Campus police, an omnipresent relic of the Ben Ali era, were reintroduced and a great “he said, she said” debate ensued. French professor Habib Mellakh reported being shoved by protestors. The dean, Habib Kazdaghli, now released, was barred entry to his office by protestors. Professors rallied in defense of the niqab ban and questioned if the Salafist protestors were indeed students or outsiders.  Salafist protestors continued to demonstrate for the right to wear the niqab and for on-campus prayer rooms.[3]

A week later, the faculty board closed the College. “We reached a stage where we could not negotiate with these people,” stated Dean Kazdaghli.

The New Year came and went, and not much improved on the campus. On January 17, students wearing the niqab began a hunger strike in an attempt to have their demands met. They bemoaned the university’s flippant approach to their cause and accused the faculty of verbal abuse. Imen Ben Rouha, one of the five students on the hunger strike, said, “We are ready to sacrifice our lives for this cause. This is our right and we are open to any dialogue that can lead to a solution to this case.”

Hunger strikes ended, and the end of February ushered in faculty strikes. On February 28th, a niqab wearing student attempted to enter a classroom.  Following the instructions of the University’s scientific council, the professor barred the student from entering class.  As the student called upon support from Salafists both at and around the university, the faculty at the College of Letters rallied in support of their colleague and began their strike. 

“Salafists are not letting us do our job. Whenever us professors try to apply the university’s law, we get physically attacked. This is not acceptable,” stated Radhia Jaidi, head of the English department. “The Faculté des Lettres is no longer a safe environment for us to teach in.”

The professors took their grievances to the Ministry of Higher Education and the General Prosecutor.  Hatem Kattou, the press attaché of the Ministry of Higher Education condemned the aggression against professors and sought a speedy solution to the situation. It seemed that none was reached.

The first week of March ushered in the suspension of two niqab wearing students, Imen Ben Rouha  and Faten Hajji, for their involvement in earlier riots. Objecting to the suspension, the two students went to the Dean’s office to protest. What happened next is disputed by both sides. English department head Amel Jaidi claims that the two students broke into the Dean’s office and when asked to leave, they destroyed his office.  The students claimed that the Dean violently attacked them; lawyers have threatened to bring a case against the Dean. 

But the niqab was just the beginning.

As Salafists rallied behind their female compatriots, one climbed up a flag post and exchanged the Tunisian flag for the black Salafist one. “One of the professors who witnessed the Tunisian flag taken down was brought to tears,” stated Manel Bejaoui, an English student at the university.

Enter the heroic female savior—this time in the flesh as opposed to her relegated position in literature: Khaoula Rashidi. Rashidi, who hails from Gafsa, is said to have climbed the wall and attempted to take down the Salafi flag, only to be beaten down. For her efforts, President Marzouki officially honored Rashidi, praising her defense of the flag, “The flag is the symbol of the country … the blood of martyrs … and the Arab-Islamic identity,” stated Marzouki.  Eventually, the Salafi flag was taken down, and the Tunisian one flown again. (It should be noted that a Salafi replaced the black Salafist flag with the Tunisian flag and Mohamed Bakhti, the spokesperson of Salafist students in Manouba, denied his movement’s involvement in the flag incident.)

Manouba’s flag and niqab debates are no longer confined to the university scene. Indeed, these topics have been catapulted into a country-wide debate about Tunisian nationalism. At the March 8, 2012 Women’s Day rally, one of the women interviewed said, “Yesterday [the Salafists] crossed a line, for us the flag is sacred, it is our identity.” Other women echoed her sentiments, adding, “Men don’t risk losing their rights, but we do.”

At the National Constituent Assembly, members put small Tunisian flags on their desks in support of Rashidi’s defense of the flag.  Some blamed the Dean for his mishandling of the situation, while others worried that the Salafist demonstrations and violent behavior were indicative of growing religious extremism. 

Tunisian politics are dangerously slipping into an us-versus-them mentality; one can only be a secularists or a salafist.  As the middle ground disappears and polarizing conversations dominate every day politics and life, the purported Arab Spring that was supposed to blanket Tunisia in democracy, might not be exactly what covers the country.  For now, the fabric of Tunisian society is tenuously held together with the fervor of college students.


[1] In 1981, wearing a hijab in a public office officially became illegal. Presidential decree 108, passed in 1985, took the ban one step further, disallowing hijab at educational institutions.

[2] Many professors argue that it is difficult to teach students when you cannot see their faces. Additionally, during exams, students are required to match their face to their ID card, a task made impossible by the niqab.

[3] See Tunisia Live’s coverage on youtube.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Four Funny Things That Happened on the Way to the Kasbah

Things that particularly pleased and amused me this week, in no particular order:

1. Today I ordered a coke and a chocolate butter croissant.  My horrified friend (and by friend I mean the cashier and chronologist of my daily chocolate crepe eating habit) replied, “Nura. Are you on a diet?!” Yup, only in Tunisia can you order a coke and a chocolate filled buttery mess and be on a diet.

2. There is a town in Tunisia called Sfax.  There, the people are called Sfaxians.  In this town of Sfax, there is a very rich family.  They are called the Fakh Fakhs. This family has a son named Fakhir Fakh Fakh.  Extrapolate as you will.

3.  I tried to describe, inexplicably, the game hide and go seek to a Tunisian friend. Confused, she switched to English and asked me if I was describing the game “hide and appear.” 

4. Tunisian Arabic bears no similarity to my four years of Arabic linguistic investment. I therefor begin my language lessons with the simplest of phrases–My name is nura. I am six years old. Last class, we reviewed the vegetables. How do you ask for an artichoke in Tunisian Arabic? Oh, that’s right. Do you have gonorrhea? 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Tunisia’s Favorite Ketchup and Mayonaise?

Image

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A Brief Hop to South Africa

I’m aware; I’ve been in Tunisia for two seconds and it hardly seems like the time to be taking vacation, but I assure you, it was for a good reason: Thulani and Fungai’s wedding! You see, years ago, Thulani became a member of the Suleiman family after surviving a summer at our house.  He then returned the favor, perhaps more than a favor, when he drove hours to come get me in a hospital in South Africa and move me to a new one. My kidneys pay homage to him on a daily basis.

I met my dahling mother in Johannesburg where we stayed with the even more dahling, Vivek (another one of the Suleiman boys).  Our first stop? The lion park! Please note, this was the closest that Vivek ever got to the lions.

Image

Image

Image

Please note, this was the closest that Vivek ever got to the lions.

The beautiful Sinotheni Mpala was also around to hang with the lions. Was so wonderful to see such a familiar face after so many years!

Image

The happy family!

Image

It should, however, be clear from the following photos that I am, in fact, a lion trainer.

ImageImage

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And the two beautiful people that brought us back to South Africa? Could they look any happier?!

Image

And my beautiful date.

Image

After Johannesburg, we headed to Cape Town, where my South African adventure began three years ago. So wonderful to see Blance under less delirious circumstances–and finally met the famous Jax!

Image

Image

Off to the penguins, who it turns out are angry creatures that bite.

ImageImage

Image

The most ferocious penguin you ever saw.

Image

To Paarl for an elegant olive oil tasting and moon rise over the mountains.

Image

Image

Image

Back to Cape Town to visit the Cape of Good Hope, the southern most point in Africa!

Last stop, sunset from Lion’s head.

Image

South Africa 2012? So much better the second time around.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The unveiling of Sami Khedira’s racy pictures and the (un)veiling of Tunisian freedom of press

I thought I’d share with you all an editorial I wrote for CEMAT (where I have this little ole fellowship): 

Image

The Picture

On February 15, 2012, the print cover of Attounissia, the self-dubbed objective post-revolution project, bore an incendiary photo: a naked Lena Gercke with her boyfriend, German-Tunisian Sami Khedira, cupping her breasts with his hands. The photo of the famed soccer star and his model girlfriend will appear on the cover of the March 2012 issue of the German GQ magazine. But in Tunisia, the picture has already scandalized the nation.

When questioned about the decision to print the outrageous photo, Habib Guizani, editor in chief of Attounissia, remarked, “Sami Khedira is a star and the picture is artistically beautiful. We knew that the (sic) it may cause some controversy, but we did not expect this kind of reaction.” In response to the publication, police arrested Guizani, along with Hedi Hediri, the editor of the world section, and Attounissia owner, Nassridine Ben Saida. They gathered 7,620 copies of the newspaper from the street and ordered censorship of copies not yet delivered . The men were taken to the Bouchoucha prison where they were charged with offending public morality.

The Charge

According to the Prosecutor, Ben Saida’s violation was simple: he had broken article 121 of the Penal Code. Article 121, paragraph 3 of the Penal Code reads, “The distribution, putting up for sale, public display, possession with the intent to distribute, sell or display for propaganda purposes, of tracts…that can harm public order or good morals, is prohibited. Any infraction…can bring about, in addition to immediate confiscation, a prison term of six months to five years and a fine of 120 to 1200 dinars.” The government, under article 121, does not have to rely on proof of said violation, but rather on the possibility that such a violation might occur.[1]

Passed in 1975 under the tenure of Habib Bouguiba and then fortified under Ben Ali, the Press Code and Penal Codes effectively led to the demise of independent reporting, as journalists were charged with defamation and criticism of public authorities.

Ben Saida’s arrest, however, should not be part of that narrative. On November 2, 2011, the government of interim Prime Minister, Beji Caid Essebsi, repealed the old law with the passage of a new press code. This time, opponents felt the new law antagonized Islam and sought to restrict religious freedom in Tunisia.[2] The law, despite criticism, has been upheld. 

The following day, Tunisia’s General Prosecutor dropped the charges against Gizani and Hediri. Ben Saida remained in prison, on a hunger strike, until his February 23rd conditional release. On March 8th, Ben Saida will return to the Court and go before judge Faouzi Jebali.

The Reaction

Attounissia’s foray into incendiary picture publication in a post-Ben Ali Tunisia has sparked a national debate about the limits of freedom of press and the morals that should govern it. Taoufik Nouira, a spokesman for Attounissia, was befuddled by the arrest. He remarked, “We thought we were living in a country where freedom of the press was respected. We did not expect this to happen at all. If we wanted to be provocative we would have published the picture without the article about Sami Khedira that we included with it.” 

Zied El Heni, a spokesperson for the 1000 journalist strong Union of Journalists, said, “We are condemning the continued detainment and arrest warrant issued against Ben Saida. The lack of professionalism of Attounissia’s editorial decision-makers does not justify the state taking away an individual’s freedom, rather this problem can be solved within the professional institutions for the journalists.” 

Reports without Borders echoed the paper’s sentiment in a press release, stating, “The threat of imprisonment sends an extremely disturbing signal to all those who defend freedom of expression. This is a hypocritical reaction because photos of this kind often appear on the cover of foreign magazines sold in Tunisia.”

In a statement to Le Temps, Rached Gannouchi, the leader of Tunisia’s largest Islamist political party, Ennahda, condemned the arrest of Ben Saida and any other form of harassment against journalists. 

A Changing Tunisia?

Ben Saida’s lawyer, Khaled Krichi, said the true motivation for the arrest could be traced to Egyptian Islamic Religious leader Sheikh Wajdi Ghoneim’s visit. During Ghoneim’s February 11th visit, he told religious radio station Zitouna, “Tunisia was the first country to have its revolution, and God willing, it will be the first to implement Sharia.”  Visits by radical clerics to Tunisia have become more frequent for the less than two-month-old Islamist-led Tunisian government. These visits have been highly controversial for many Tunisian rights activists, who had become accustomed to a secular rule under previous authoritarian governments.

While the freeing of Guizani and Hediri seems to be indicative of a Tunisia that is willing to correct its mistakes, only the court’s ruling on Ben Saida’s case will determine how far Tunisia has really come.

Sources

Feuillatre, Cecile. “Tunisian activists file suit against female circumcision preacher.” Middle East Online. 15 February 2012.

Ghribi, Asma. “Publisher of Racy Sami Khedira Photo Released From Prison.” Tunisia Live Online 23 February 2012. 

Mzioudet, Houda. “Tunisia’s Union of Journalists on Strike.” Tunisia Live Online 13 December 2011.

Shadid, Anthony. “Tunisia Navigates a Democratic Path Tinged With Religion.” New York Times Online 30 January 2012. 

Shirayanagi, Kouichi. “General Prosecutor Frees Two Newsmen But Continues Detainment of Paper’s Owner in Sami Khedira Photo Publiction Case.” Tunisia Live Online 16 February 2012. 

Shirayanagi, Kouichi. “Newsmen Arrested in Tunis After Publication of Racy Sami Khedira Photo.” Tunisia Live Online 15 February 2012. 

Shirayanagi, Kouichi. “Pre-Trial Journalists Arrested for Publication of Sami Khedira Photo.” Tunisia Live Online 16 February 2012. 


[1] See the April 25, 2002 case of lawyer Mohamed Abbou for more information. Abbou served more than two years in prison for publishing an article comparing prisons in Tunisia to those in Abu Ghraib.

[2] Article 51 of the new code allows the imprisonment of “persons who incite discrimination, the use of heinous and violent means, propagation of racial segregation, religious extremism, and regional or tribal conflict.”  Additionally controversial is Article 59, pertaining to places of worship.  

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Kaplan!

My obsession with my dog is no secret. So imagine my surprise when Kaplan’s twin showed up in Tunis. Luckily no one was around to witness my post-almost-Kaplan sighting meltdown.

I was quite taken with this beach side hotel, figuring that there was a story behind it. I typed “hotel amilcar” into tripadvisor.  Imagine my surprise at the following review, “This hotel highly misrepresented itself on the internet, the hotel looks fairly new or recent in its internet photos.” Yes, shorebest123, yes.  You were duped.

Some parting shots of neighborhood doors.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Hilly Runs and Headpieces

Found at the magazine stand next to my office: whoever pops out the next one will receive this fine addition to any children’s literature collection.

Views from runs around the neighborhood.  Inexplicably, I find myself living in the flattest part of hilly towns.  This means that in order to go anywhere, I have to either walk up a gigantic mountain or down one, only to walk up said mountain later.  I wonder what this says about my personality. (All these pictures have been taken with my iPhone–eventually, I’ll lug the camera around and take some real shots!).

 

 

 

 

I thought that this was a belt, or, even, perhaps, a necklace.  Nope.  Thanks to the shopkeeper, this is apparently how you wear it…

It’s been an exciting couple of days in Tunis. Secretary Clinton’s arrival to questionably/potentially/who knows at this point send arms to the Syrians stirred up  protests in town, which I happened to (literally) walk right into. I feel fortunate that I don’t have any friends in country yet, so that I don’t have to explain my country’s decision making process.

I’m finding that I speak just enough Arabic and French to have absolutely no clue what people are saying to me. It’s a rare nicety to go through each day having absolutely no clue what people are saying to you.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Tuesday, February 22, 2012: The Perfume Cab Driver

Mint tea with pinenuts at Café des Nattes

View from Café Sidi Chabaâne

The Perfume Cab Driver

We started choking immediately. We rolled down the windows to stick out our heads like dogs, but his cologne was so overwhelming that not even riding in a hot air balloon with him could mask his scent. Instantaneously, he snapped back for me to shut it.  The cab driver leaned to his right and opened the vacant passenger seat window instead.

But sir, we stammered, your perfume is too strong. We cannot tolerate it back here.

He quipped back, that’s why I opened the front window.

Befuddled, we replied, but that’s not helping us breathe back here.

He turned around, but it’s helping me. I cannot stand your perfumes.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment